Elk Mountain Lodge
CASTLE CREEK, ASPEN
125 Rooney Circle, Castle Creek, Aspen, Colorado
Branded residence
The first Eleven Experience property managed as a short-term rental lodge. Elk Mountain Lodge is a natural fit for the brand, and the partnership re-establishes it as a world-class, one-of-a-kind lodge — elevating its value.
01 — Value
The lodge traded well below the price per square foot of Aspen’s other large-home sales, and Pitkin County’s new plan points to rules under which a home this size could not be built again.
Price per square foot, large single-family sales
Still below replacement cost.
The comparables are closer to town than Castle Creek, which accounts for part of the gap. Elk Mountain Lodge is also the largest of the six at 25,277 sq ft, on 52.2 acres.
| Property | Sold | Price | Sq ft | Per sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 419 Willoughby Way | Apr 2024 | $108.0M | 22,405 | $4,820 |
| 730 S Galena Street | May 2023 | $65.0M | 14,154 | $4,592 |
| 45101 Highway 82 | Aug 2023 | $63.8M | 15,000 | $4,250 |
| 1011 Ute Avenue | Sep 2026 | $63.5M | 17,544 | $3,619 |
| 1001 Ute Avenue | Sep 2023 | $76.0M | 21,500 | $3,535 |
| Elk Mountain Lodge (sold) | Jul 2026 | $37.8M | 25,277 | $1,495 |
| Elk Mountain Lodge at $60M | — | $60.0M | 25,277 | $2,374 |
Source: Aspen/Glenwood MLS closed sales. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
A discount driven by perception, not the property
Elk Mountain Lodge’s sale price reflects how the market came to see it more than what it is. Three things worked against it.
Opening Elk Mountain Lodge to guests through Eleven Experience is central to our plan. It restores the property’s reputation and gives the next buyer the chance to experience it before they buy.
Pitkin County house-size limits
Pitkin County’s maximum house size was 15,000 sq ft until 2023, when it dropped to 9,250 sq ft. The Land Use Code is now expected to lower it again, to 8,750 sq ft. Replacing Elk Mountain Lodge’s 25,277 sq ft today would take three adjacent parcels. One 16,000 sq ft lodge with five cabins on a single parcel is rare and irreplaceable.
Sources: Pitkin County Vision 2050 · Comp Plan P&Z hearing, March 17, 2026 · Ordinance 036-2023. The 8,750 sq ft limit takes effect once the Land Use Code is amended.
02 — Property photos
Elk Mountain Lodge today fits the character of Eleven Experience lodges. With a light remodel to the Eleven standards it can become a world-class lodge property.
Each row pairs a photo of Elk Mountain Lodge on the left with a comparable space at an Eleven Experience lodge on the right.
A log lodge on Castle Creek, bordered on three sides by the White River National Forest.
Fitness center, a 30-foot Great Room and ten fireplaces across the property.
Fifteen bedrooms across the main house and seven cabins.
Room to host a full house — a long table, a working kitchen and a den.
03 — By the numbers
Elk Mountain Lodge against the closest points of reference: the Eleven Experience portfolio in Crested Butte and the nearby Dunbar Ranch at the base of Independence Pass.
CASTLE CREEK, ASPEN
SCARP RIDGE, SOPRIS HOUSE & PUBLIC HOUSE LOFTS
INDEPENDENCE PASS, ASPEN
Eleven square footage is approximate, combined across the three Crested Butte properties. Dunbar Ranch acreage and square footage per Pitkin County Assessor across four parcels; bed and bath count per MLS.
04 — Rental comp
The closest rental comp in Aspen shows what an event-ready estate here commands.
05 — Rental economics
Renting accomplishes two goals:
| Season | Weeks | Weekly rate | Gross revenue |
|---|---|---|---|
| Summer | 9 | $236,000 – $357,000 | $2.13M – $3.21M |
| Winter | 7 | $217,000 – $322,000 | $1.52M – $2.25M |
| Total | 16 | $228,000 – $342,000 avg | $3.65M – $5.47M |
Net to owner after 40% Eleven fee (placeholder): $2.19M conservative – $3.28M upside.
| Item | Annual |
|---|---|
| Taxes + PM salary + opex (insurance, utilities, maintenance) | $644,000 – $758,000 |
| Debt service (60% LTV, $24.0M loan, 7% interest-only) | $1,680,000 |
| Net cash flow after all costs — conservative | ≈ –$0.19M |
| Net cash flow after all costs — upside | ≈ +$0.90M |
Down payment $16.0M + remodel $7.5M (midpoint of $5–10M) = $23.5M total equity invested.
06 — Pro forma
Buy at $40.0M, remodel to Eleven's standard, rent under the county cap, and sell in Year 5 through a 1031 exchange.
Sale price, $/sq ft and equity multiple at 60% LTV with a 1031 exchange. Choose an exit price.
| Sale price | $ / sq ft | Conservative multiple | Upside multiple |
|---|
Five-year equity multiple sensitivity, largest lever first.
07 — Video tour
Short walkthroughs of the main lodge, each guest cabin and the gym. Each video opens on Vimeo in a new tab.
Three videos, one per floor or wing
Six guest cabins and the gym, largest to smallest
08 — FAQ
Location, county rules, capacity and the guest experience.
About 20 minutes by car, roughly the same drive as Snowmass Village to Aspen.
The county allows up to 120 rental nights a year, with a 4-night minimum per booking. Up to three events a year may have more than 50 guests, with a cap of 200 people per event. Gatherings of fewer than 50 people don’t need a permit.
About 34 guests across 17 bedrooms, based on two people per bedroom. That count doesn’t include bunk beds.
Mostly new furniture, fixtures and equipment (FF&E). Some cabin bathrooms may need updating, and air conditioning would be added to the bedrooms. A more complete spa is also being considered.
Yes. Nearly all of the furniture from the auction sale stays with the property. Only the previous owner’s artwork and personal items were removed.